Dec 2, 2018

The Future of Humanity

Today's rather pretentiously named update will be picking up on the rewrite of the Sanity and Humanity rules from last time. Here, let me quote where we last left off:

"The one idea that comes to mind would be writing in again the discarded plot element of humans transforming into Fiends and replacing Sanity with Humanity entirely. This would be, in essence, the deletion of Humanity as it exists and giving Sanity a makeover in terms of what it represents in game. I still don't have any clear rules in mind to represent PCs that have become Fiends and they would also need a page or two of advice telling groups how to handle the going berserk scenario, concluding in how to either bring them back to Humanity 1 or making them antagonists permanently."

It's probably not a surprise that I ended up going more or less with what is quoted above. The changes list proper is as follows:


  • Humanity mechanic deleted. For the sake of clarity, the original mechanic will be called oHumanity when it is relevant to the discussion.
  • Sanity mechanic renamed to Humanity. Conceptually, Humanity tracks how much in control of your powers you are, losing control and becoming a monster at 0.
  • Characters do not lose Humanity from burning down orphanages or kicking puppies. It is not a morality mechanic like oHumanity was.
  • Characters do not lose Humanity from traumatic experiences. It is not a madness mechanic like Sanity was.
  • Characters lose Humanity as a consequence of Twists, using certain Tricks, Negotiation and using Limit Breaks. In essence, Humanity loss cannot be forced on PCs and is always at the control of the player.
  • Characters can now Limit Break to gain Orgone Points during combat. Each Orgone Point gained this way results in a loss of 1 Humanity, from a starting maximum of 10.
  • Listening Negotiation Skill renamed to Contact. It represents mentally contacting the target and seeing a glimpse of their life through their eyes.


The gist of it is that now Humanity represents the purity of your orgone field and how much control you have over it. When you mess with it too much, such as by storing parts of it in a philactery, making mental contact with another or pushing it past your body's safe limits, it corrupts. When you fail to purify it regularly and let it corrupt too much, it transforms you into a monster known as a Fiend. Sanity and oHumanity were related to many other rules, so let's do a quick skim of all the other stuff that got affected.

First and most obviously, we no longer have a morality mechanic. I considered keeping the oHumanity mechanic as a Reputation system, but honestly it wasn't that good anyway and it doesn't really seem like a big loss to cut it. The consequence here is that there's less modifiers to Negotiation Tests (which is fine, those are always super dependent on their context anyway) and less ways to lose Sanity Humanity, which is addressed by the rest of the rules. All's fine on this end.

Second is how it affects the Bonus/Twist economy, or rather, how it doesn't. One of my worries with doing significant changes to Sanity was that it would make the lives of PCs much harder by giving them less things they could afford to lose on the events of rolling a bad string of Twists. Humanity fills Sanity's shoes as if Sanity had never left us, so that's a plus. The corruption of your orgone is not as easy to justify as stress making you go crazier and more radical, but it is always a player choice so they can just use it when appropriate. Of note: You can never cure your own Humanity, another PC has to help you.

Third is how Limit Breaks affect combat and class balance. The game was actually very well balanced on the PC vs NPC side before this last series of changes (most notably the removal of Character Feats) tilted things towards favoring NPCs quite a bit. The addition of Limit Breaks helps push the PC side of fights quite a bit, to the point where it potentially makes PCs near-invincible if they're willing to burn tons of Humanity. I suspect most combat scenes will end with all PCs losing 1 Vitality, 1 Humanity or both, which is more or less how it was with Sanity before.

Fourth is the Listening Negotiation Skill, which used to trade a point of Sanity for doing a ton of HP Damage. With Humanity this is no longer conceptually feasible, so it's being renamed to Contact and the Humanity damage is represented as a loss of self from becoming someone else for a round of combat. It's not a big change, especially if you're reskinning what the negotiation skills do, but it bears mentioning.

Lastly there's Obsessions and the potential of character retirement. Nearly all Obsessions were rewritten at the low end of the scale to properly represent a transformation into a Fiend (or Majin as the blurb calls them). Fiends are, in essence, serial killers themed around their obsession. The more they indulge the extreme ends of their obsession, the stronger they get, and if they do it while going on a killing spree and feeding on the life energy of their victims they get twice as much. Humans that change into Fiends still look the same and Fiends don't belong to any of the 12 playable Monster races. There's more, obviously (they've a whole page detailing their behavior, how to cure them and a feature of their own as NPCs) but this is getting long enough already. I want to end this bit making it explicitly clear that the default approach to PCs with 0 Humanity is restraining and healing them so that they become human PCs again.

And that about sums it up, I think. The new Humanity rules are much more focused on giving PCs the opportunity to string combos of limit techs and do cool things on the mechanical side while encouraging character development and tight party relationships. I suspect a lot of tough fights will end with a PC breaking the limits of their power level, going berserk, and getting saved by the power of FRIENDSHIP. And I think that's awesome.

Gimmick Out.

Nov 11, 2018

From Monsterpunk v0.9 to v0.91

Monsterpunk v0.9 is about one month and half old and I already have a pretty good idea of where to go next with it. Today I'm going to go over what is going to get changed and why. Without further ado, let's get started.

Removing Character Feats & Role Techs


The list of 32 Feats that grant minor combat bonuses and the Limit Techs that Gestalts & Ubermensch get based on their class role are going to be deleted. Because this changes all Character Classes considerably, they're all going to get some small tweaks as follows:


  • All Character Classes get an extra Archetype Feat while leveling up. This is slightly weaker than getting 4 Character Feats while leveling up, but the Archetypes are 1) more impactful 2) more unique 3) more fun so it more or less balances out.
  • Gestalt Classes get an additional Monster Feat and 5 HP. Gestalts need to compensate for the loss of Role Techs and they were already lagging behind slightly Riders and Ubermensch, so now they get to be the tankiest class type. I think it suits them, conceptually.
  • Rider Classes get an additional 2 Speed. Riders were fine for the most part and should still continue to be, since they and Summoners lose the least. They still get a minor bonus to Speed to further distinguish them from others. RIP Fleet of Foot.
  • Summoner Classes get an additional Monster Feat. Summoners are powerful but hard to play, very vulnerable to area of effect attacks and rely on Character Feats to improve their survivability and solve their mobility problems. Getting an additional Monster Feat should help fix whichever is the biggest problem for each specific build.
  • Ubermensch Classes get an additional Archetype Feat, Basic Tech & Support Tech that can be taken from the list of ANY Character Class (but not Monster Classes) and lose 5 HP and 2 Speed. The biggest problem with Ubermensch is that, while powerful, they lack versatility. Everyone else starts with 2 Basic & Support Techs plus an extra noticeably powerful Feat from their Monster. Ubermensch instead get... bonus HP and Speed. Yawn. This change opens them up to lots of new possible builds and makes them a lot less repetitive to play.


But why am I removing Character Feats & Role Techs from the game entirely? Isn't that a little extreme? To best answer that I should first explain why they exist at all.

Character Feats are easy. See, I like PC customization (big shocker there, I know). At first all the Classes were just a big pile of Techs with Monster Feats tacked on... I feared this would make them boring from a CharOp standpoint and repetitive in terms of viable builds, particularly Ubermensch which didn't have Monsters at all. So I made the 32 Character Feats and allowed everyone to have some, giving Ubermensch an extra four. One of the things I wanted to do with Monsterpunk compared to BCG was get more from the Advantage/Disadvantage tradeoff mechanic, so I wrote in a bunch of Feats that granted conditional Advantages or inflicted conditional Disadvantages. Combined with conditional Advantages/Disadvantages from Terrain or status conditions, players would have to be maneuvering around the battlefield and combining their forces to stack Advantages in such a way that negated defensive Disadvantages and made things more interesting.

Role Techs have a more complex story. Originally Gestalts and Ubermensch could additional Orgone Points in combat if they performed secondary objectives based on their role (marking enemies, causing status conditions, healing allies, etc.), the idea was that these classes had conceptually higher orgone reserves since their energy wasn't divided between two entities. Because this was extremely powerful (consider that a single Orgone Point starts in power as a +5 HP heal and get better the more Limit Techs you have) I had to scrap the idea of bonus Orgone Points entirely. I flipped the idea on its head and, instead of rewarding in-role behavior with a power boost made it so that they had conditional but powerful ways to fulfill their combat role. At the moment, I thought that was a clever solution.

So what is wrong with them? Well, they're both boring. Worse, they're boring and bog things down. Role Techs had flavor, once, but now they just seem like they're tacked on to their classes because they needed something more and, instead of giving them something fun, they got some conditionally useful abilities. Character Feats slow down combat by making people have to calculate the total of Advantages/Disadvantages constantly and there's so many of them that players often forget one or more of them. While this is something I did have in mind when I made it so that they could be traded for a +1 or -1 to the result post-roll should someone forget them, they're still annoying to track.

This leads to the next problem, one that is partly shared with Role Techs, that they could be fun instead of annoying, but they aren't. That's because there's too many of them and they're, for the most part, on the weaker side of things. Role Techs don't suffer the complexity problem, but they do suffer from being marginally useful. Also, they're the worst part of character creation and leveling up. Picking your Techs? Fun. Picking your Archetype and Monster Feats? That's a big factor deciding what kind of character you'll make. Picking Character Feats & Role Techs? Gets old halfway through. Add all these things together and both Character Feats and Role Techs take more from the game than they add to it, so I'm deleting them from the character creation process.

By doing away with the tons of weak abilities and giving everyone more of the strong abilities, the loss of customization and power is minimized and PCs get to have more cool stuff and the game flows faster. I may make some additional tweaks to the class changes posted above, but I think you get the idea of the direction I want to take them in.

Rewriting or removing the Sanity & Humanity rules.


Okay so... This one is a bit more complex to explain. Let's start with what Sanity & Humanity are supposed to represent. A big theme of the game is the difference between humans and monsters and what it means to be human. As a mechanical reinforcement of this theme, Sanity & Humanity give PCs have an arc about going bad and getting better. Loss of Humanity wasn't just supposed to end in the PC turning evil, but in an actual transformation into a monster.

Yes, all packmakers (including Gestalts) could transform into a different kind of monster (much like Demons can transform into Angels) by turning into a Fiend, a kind of monster utterly possessed by a singular obsession that it pursues with psychopathic glee. The idea was that PCs could slowly warp over time into such a being and either do some course correction before it was too late or go berserk until the party pacified them, depending on what would serve the story better.

The problem here was that I couldn't come up with any good rules for this berserk mode transformation and it seemed like the kind of rule that needed a lot of story baggage to support it, so I ditched the Fiend bits and figured maybe I could come back to it later in an expansion or something if there was interest in it. I kept the Sanity & Humanity rules because Sanity is part of the Vitality/Sanity/Wealth trifecta that keeps the Twist/Success system going and Humanity plays into the game's focus on Negotiation as a thing, so I figured they'd do more good than bad.

I, uh, have had some passionate discussions on the subject as of late that have led me to change my opinion on the matter.

Y'see, my experience with mechanics like this has been mostly a good one, because I've always used them and seen them used as roleplaying incentives, so I tend to underestimate the potential for things to go wrong with them. Unfortunately, we live in a world where paladins falling for bullshit reasons is so frequent that it is a meme, so I can't really just throw these rules at people and expect them to use them in a way that is fun for everyone. Iy mind, while permanent retirement from Sanity & Humanity are options, they're better used to tell stories of human weakness and redemption. It is a temporary retirement until the party heals the PC from the brink of total assholery... Or, failing that, about allies that turn into antagonists.

I guess I could've communicated that better. Whoops!

Point is, something must be done about Sanity & Humanity. But what, exactly? Well, Humanity isn't a big loss as it is disconnected from most other rules, but Sanity loss/restoration is a common twist/success result and something would need to replace their loss in gameplay terms.

The one idea that comes to mind would be writing in again the discarded plot element of humans transforming into Fiends and replacing Sanity with Humanity entirely. This would be, in essence, the deletion of Humanity as it exists and giving Sanity a makeover in terms of what it represents in game. I still don't have any clear rules in mind to represent PCs that have become Fiends and they would also need a page or two of advice telling groups how to handle the going berserk scenario, concluding in how to either bring them back to Humanity 1 or making them antagonists permanently.

I guess I could just... Not have special rules for this and just write advice instead. That works, I suppose. It's quite a bit of work but the idea is conceptually cool enough that I'm willing to go there. I'm a lot less sure about this one so, while feedback is always appreciated, it is most valued here.

Coming this Christmas


And that's what's going to be worked on next. If things go well this'll be done right before the end of the year. We're approaching the time of the year where hardware around me starts to explode so fingers crossed that all goes to plan.

Gimmick Out.

Oct 28, 2018

From Megaten to Monsterpunk

The process of figuring out what to take and what to discard from Monsterpunk's chief inspiration was much more interesting than it was with BCG. Combat in tabletop RPGs is basically playing a multiplayer co-op tactics game where each player controls a single unit. It was a matter of figuring out which mechanics were worth keeping, which ones needed some massaging for an adaptation and which ones to discard. Compared to what I had to do for Monsterpunk, BCG was basically designing on autopilot. This is primarly for two reasons.

First is that the franchise is a lot more experimental with its mechanics. Digital Devil Saga is like a traditional jrpg without demon negotiation or fusion, Persona is a dating sim with simplified SMT mechanics bolted on top and the Raidou games throw real time action into the mix. Even the mainline games have radically different mechanics from title to title, with Nocturne being radically different from SMT 1+2 and IV+Apocalypse being radically different from Nocturne. You could probably take any of those titles and adapt any one of them, but you can't really adapt all of them at once without taking some creative liberties.

Second is that the mechanics that are common to most series are extremely videogamey or simply unfeasible in a co-op multiplayer environment. Press turns are a great JRPG turn-based system but only really work when one player = one team and having 4+ teams running around, each using press turns, would be a huge mess. Demon fusion is flat out impossible to translate in a way that doesn't involve tons of charts and spreadsheets while still retaining what makes it interesting. Giving all PCs a rotating roster of demons that constantly changes as the result of negotiation, fusion and plot means having a ton of insignificant NPCs running around instead of a handful of meaningful ones. Point here is that it's not just that most mechanics are different from game to game, but the ones that tend to stick between games aren't the kind of thing you actually want in a tabletop game.

Do note that I already knew this was going to be a system where most PCs would control and fight with monsters, which was already very difficult to adapt to the tabletop RPG experience while keeping it elegant. Having a system like that that wasn't Pokemon was the entire reason that I set out to make the game in the first place, but I certainly didn't need to make it more complicated than it already was.

What about instead designing around the aesthetics, worldbuilding and general tone of the franchise? Those also change a lot from game to game (purists still argue that Persona is not a 'real' SMT game, after all), but if I cherry-picked a handful of them I could adapt them to a pen and paper RPG, which is more than I could do for the mechanics.

Here's the List of SMT Things That I Decided To Focus Around:

1) Mythology Kitchen Sink
The games feature tons of mythological characters in it, ranging from the well-known to the obscure, but they're not just window-dressing. You can reasonably expect accurate lore from them, which the plot is written around. Satan is a different character from and enemy of Lucifer, Shiva is a god of destruction and rebirth rather than a lady with ice powers, Loki is a trickster instrumental in the fall of the otherwise invincible and immortal Baldur. Mixing so many contradictory mythologies together means sacrificing some fidelity, yes, but so does telling a good story where the PCs get to do anything of relevance and the plot isn't already written in stone. I wanted to cram as much mythology into the game as possible, so I figured I'd go for five factions instead of two or three, which leads us right to...

2) Moral Extremism
In SMT the factions are extremist assholes. The demons, too, are extremist assholes. Even your friends are extremist assholes! The commonly agreed best ending in most games is not allying with anyone but murdering all of them, because most of the people vying for power in these games are up to nothing good. Usually the conflict is between Law (aka God) and Chaos (aka Lucifer), but if you've ever played D&D you know that the Law/Chaos divide isn't a particularly consistent one, so I would have factions focusing on more concrete goals. I have the WAR! faction the SCIENCE! faction the NATURE! faction the ROBOTS! faction and the FUCK DINOSAURS MONSTERS faction! I also added Obsessions to mirror how people who might start out reasonable sometimes take deep swerves into loontown, a SMT staple.

3) Grimcamp Edgebright Tone
The games head into pretty dark territory. It doesn't stop at killing as a way to solve problems, it usually involves brainwashing, slavery and flat out genocide as things that players have to stop or can choose to support. Still, there's moments of levity, from dancing with Mr. Thriller in hell to Charon telling you to go take a number and whining about the queue when you get a game over. The shifts in tone can be very quick: one moment you're watching a teenager try to kill herself to escape a sex offender and the other you're fighting a giant penis demon. First you're dramatically shooting yourself in the head to summon a demon, later you're putting a shock collar on a dog so he can do the same. The tone is only consistent in its inconsistency. Between snarky commentary from named NPCs in most sections and completely ridiculous shit being treated with stone cold seriousness (such as everything about Orgone), I think I've got the tone right.

4) Negotiation Matters
Demon Negotiation is one of the highlights of these games, the quirky conversations you can have with demons (or that your demons can have with other demons) are a big draw into the setting, but the inherent randomness in the system is often a turn off. It is also one of the most frustrating things about the franchise, because you have a bunch of games where talking to others is an actual game mechanic, yet significant enemies simply refuse to do so. I wanted to make Negotiations a big deal in Monsterpunk, so I figured that instead of making one PC the dedicated face of the team everyone would have a Talky PC Skill they could use. Negotiations are relevant in combat not just as a way to finish things but also as a way to weaken enemies, they're a thing that anyone can do but that still feels unique for each PC. I'm quite proud of how this one turned out.

5) Making Pacts for Power
Many of the games begin with the main character signing a contract with an entity, this usually saves their lives when they're in danger thus ending the tutorial. Monsterpunk pretty much takes it for granted that this is going to be the origin story of most PCs. I decided there would be some pure human classes focusing on technology instead of making pacts with monsters early on to add some variety, but otherwise this is the heart of the game and the thing that makes most of its PCs stand out. It being last in the list does not mean it being least in importance.

And I think that's all. What started as making a Megaten RPG ended up being a Megaten-flavored RPG that is better described as "Devilman meets Fallout" instead. BCG is clearly and blatantly SRW, but Monsterpunk is not Megaten. Is that better? Worse? That's not for me to decide.

Next: Changes! What things I'm thinking of putting on the chopping block.

Gimmick Out.

Oct 7, 2018

From Point-Buy to Class/Level

There are some very obvious similarities between BCG and Monsterpunk, such as both systems being effects-based, the use of advantages/disadvantages and being blatant videogame ripoffs inspired by cult videogame franchises. But there are also very striking differences, and of these the most important one is that one system is point-buy while the other is class/level.

I'm a point-buy guy. Most of the time when I play games with classes and levels I don't like them. The classes are too restrictive in flavor or mechanics while the levels are the game's fun police telling you that you're not tall enough to do the cool things that you're playing the game to do.

So why would I make a class and level game, then? Because I think it works best for the kind of game that Monsterpunk is. That and because I tried to make it point-buy and it just wasn't working out. You can read more about how that happened here.

Classes and Levels: The Good


There are two primary benefits to going with a class/level system:

It is easier to balance. When you have to make sure that every single power, weapon or what have you works well not just with each other but also doesn't accidentally break the game's balance (or, worse, make it stop functioning altogether) then you spend a lot of time fine-tuning all the numbers and hunting down unintended interactions that could spell the game's doom if left unchecked. BCG and BCZ (particularly the latter) have had quite a few hiccups with powerful synergies that spiraled out of control. In a class-based game you don't have to worry about how dangerous the A+B combo is if I keep option A to the classes that don't get option B. Similarily, if the class with option A is weaker than the class with option B then I can simply make it stronger without worrying about how much that might make the class with option B even stronger.

It is easier to grok characters and make them with. Character creation takes time. This is especially true when you have to do math, such as in point-buy, instead of just going through a checklist which is what you often do with class/level systems. Creating PCs and NPCs alike in BCG is much faster than in any edition of D&D, but it doesn't seem that way because you have to do quite a bit of math, while in D&D you can just pick the guy that swings the sword, choose his kind of sword, pick some feats that make you swing swords better and call it a day. Monsterpunk characters are very easy and fast to make, and in a game like this where most PCs are actually two characters that wouldn't be possible without a class/level system.

Classes and Levels: The Bad


Now there are also some problems present in class/level systems but I think I've managed to sidestep nearly if not all of them. Point-buy systems offer freedom at the cost of complexity while class/level systems offer simplicity at the cost of freedom. Here's how:

Classes don't restrict you from playing the character concept you like. While Monsterpunk classes are more interesting and less generic than "guy with a sword" or "lady that heals", they're still broad enough that you can tweak them to your liking. Furthermore, the game is trivially easy to reskin, so this is not a problem.

Classes don't restrict you mechanically. In addition to having a good 2-3 obvious ways to build any of the classes, you can mix and match them with different monsters to get many more combinations of abilities and allowing you to combine nearly all of them to give your PC whatever you want. The caveat here is that this doesn't apply to Ubermensch classes, which, well, I admit am not super happy about... But 12 out of 16 is a pretty good total! Oh right, also there's dual and custom class systems in the back of the book, so yeah.

The level system doesn't gate you out of anything. Levels make PCs stronger over time, yes, and high level PCs play fundamentally differently from low level PCs (having two Advanced Techs or starting with an Orgone Point is a world of difference) but it doesn't dangle all the cool and fun abilities like a carrot in front of you and tell you that you don't get to use them until you've reached some arbitrary benchmark. It's more like being at the candy store and being told you can get anything but not everything.

Classes and Levels: The Ugly Conclusion


I've written at length about BCG's many issues and of those the ones I dislike the most are how difficult it is to start playing if you're not a mechanically oriented type of player. There's a lot of emphasis in what makes things easier for groups that are picking up the game for the first time, which I think is one of the big draws of having classes. However, Monsterpunk is also an experiment in trying to use a class/level while doing away with all the things I dislike about class/level systems.

Whether I've succeeded or not is up to you all to decide. Ultimately, this is an open beta, and I'm well aware that I'll probably have to change a bunch of things. I don't think I'm going to change the class/level system, but I do think I might have to work more on the custom class system if there's enough clamor for a point-buy alternative.

That's all for today! This and more were originally going to be part of last week's post but I was out of energy like half a paragraph into the class/level chat so I decided to leave that for next week. Not really sure what the next post is going to tackle, it's probably going to be more first impression stuff, I imagine.

Until then, Gimmick Out.

Sep 30, 2018

I Made Another Game

I almost missed making an update this month, but I actually managed to pull it off. More importantly, I've got something to show for all I've been doing this entire time.


Here There Be Links:

Monsterpunk v09 Beta
Monsterpunk Character Sheets
Monsterpunk Tech Cards and Feat Sheet

I'll save up the big posts about the game for a later time and just get this out the door ASAP. Right now I need to do something that doesn't involve writing, proofreading or math.

...That leaves surprisingly little, actually.

GLHF.

Next: A lot of writing, proofreading and math... Probably.

Gimmick Out.

Aug 12, 2018

The Battle Century Errata, Troubleshooting & Balance Changes Documents

Monsterpunk is on the horizon, but before I fully reveal it to the world I want to do one last thing for BCG. That's these three documents here:

Errata

This is the most important document and the one that will could get integrated into the books proper. Most of it are fixes editorial mistakes, clarifying complex rules text or rewrites to rules that just plain didn't work properly. There are a couple of mechanical changes, but they're the kind that address multiple issues with the game rather than being pure balance changes. It saves me time to change a general rule as errata here instead of adding a bunch of balance change suggestions in its place for the documents below.

Troubleshooting

This section is too large to add it to the books, so it's going to stay as a google document. As the name says, it is basically a FAQ, mostly involving quirky rules interactions. Most of the questions come from the comments section and the discord server. Some of the answers may contradict things I've said in the past, and if they do, you should consider what is in this document to be my final word on the subject.

Balance Changes

Last, but not least, a bunch of suggestions to improve your BCG + BCZ experience. They're just that, though, suggestions. Most of them are strict improvements to the rules, but if there's something you don't like in them, you can just pick and choose what to use what to leave in there. Want to nerf Absolute Barrier but don't want to cap Tension? Cool, that's why this is a google doc of suggestions only.

And now a quick FAQ:

Are you going to make more content for BCG?
No. Consider these documents a parting gift to the game, at least until I decide it is time to rebuild the whole system for a second edition.

What if the errata needs its own errata?
The documents are open to comments, so if you spot a typo, are confused about a ruling or have a suggestion about a balance change, leave it there.

So you will be updating these documents?
I'll probably do a round of typo fixes later at the least and continue to answer more questions for eternity. Mmmaybe I'll add some additional suggestions or tweak existing ones later, but no promises there. If I do it, don't expect it to be a regular thing.

I found another typo, can you add it to the errata doc?
Leave it in the errata document as a comment somewhere and I will get to it eventually.

When can we expect the PDFs to be errataed?
Probably by the end of the year. I want this to be the last errata update, so I'll wait to make sure that we won't need future errata fixes.

That's it! I may do the rest of BCZ as a Retrospective at some point, but the next thing I want to talk about is my new game. With any luck, the next post will be about Monsterpunk's open beta.

Until then!

Gimmick Out.

Jul 8, 2018

BCZ Retrospective XXVI: New Boss Capstones

BCG games where the whole PC Squad takes on a solo Superboss ended up being way more common than I expected, and Capstones are the only mechanic that lets Bosses keep up with 3+ PCs of a PL higher than 1 right out of the gate. They still need a little bit of help from things like additional Grunts, going for PLs 6 and above, or Component Rivals to combine with, but of these three options the only one that doesn't involve the creation of additional NPCs is going for a higher PL and granting them more Capstones.

With only 6 Capstones in the core rules, that's going to get repetitive fast. Fight a Boss with Energy Drain or Possession once and it's a challenging, different encounter from the norm. Fight a Boss with Energy Drain and Possession every Operation... And it's going to cross the line into being an annoying experience.

In BCZ I tried to add just enough Capstones to improve variety while including more GM advice and premade Grunt/Rival builds meant for accompanying Bosses without stealing the spotlight from them.

While the system is clearly not meant for a constant stream of 4v1 boss fights (or 3v1, 5v1, etc), I think that all the additions should be enough to run 10-15 operations that manage to stay fresh the whole way. What if you want more than 20? Probably not going to happen. The system is clearly not meant for Boss rushes and it can only be stretched so much.

Anyway, on to the capstones themselves!

All Becomes Dust
This ability is meant to represent some kind of entropic energy-draining aura, so in hindsight it should've also created Anti-Air versions of the Withering and Extreme Terrain to go with the default Anti-Ground ones. That would've made it way more powerful, yes, but it costs a ton of Energy to hit multiple PCs and touching a sniper with it is just plain unrealistic. Maybe I could tweak the Energy cost to rebalance the stronger version around it. Anyway, other than that slight flavor fail, I think it's a pretty solid Capstone that forces PCs to stay away or get wrecked, which is how I think close quarters Capstones should work.

My Final Masterpiece
The best and most known example I can think of for this ability is the third Lavos fight from Crono Trigger, but I'm sure you've seen this idea executed in other games as well. One interesting difference from the way this kind of Boss usually goes in BCG from videogames is that, while you'd think that the ability encourages aggressive Bosses protected by a tanky Grunt, it actually works better if you create a glass cannon Grunt and use the Boss to buff and heal them constantly. Without even trying to get creative, it is trivial to make a unit with Might 10 that spams a Hyper Launcher with You are in my Sights and gets resurrected every time you bring it down. If you focus the Boss, the Grunt gets more buffs and if you focus the Grunt it gets revived anyway! I think it makes more sense in-world for the big bad to beef up their pet and let it do the carrying, even if that isn't how the trope usually goes.

The Ultimate Shield
Grunts and Rivals are expected to have Active Defenses, but Bosses don't have those. This can end up making builds that rely on abilities that ignore Active Defenses (instead of attack bonuses) weaker than usual, so I opted to make Boss Upgrades like Adaptive Morphology and Afterimages count as Active Defenses. As I've already said, one of the problems with the Active Defenses that Bosses get is that they're only active after they've already taken a beating... And they're only at their best when they're near death. The Ultimate Shield solves this problem by being a Capstone and thus being active for the entire fight, making barrier-piercing attacks that much more valuable. I may have gone overboard, honestly, because +10 Defense is kind of a lot to punch through the old fashioned way. It's one of the most effective and easy to use Capstones in the game, forcing PCs to either ignore barriers or cause direct Damage if they want to win.

Tyrant of Lost Souls
Lastly, we have I Accept your Offering but as a passive ability. Usually the best way to deal with a Boss and its minions is to ignore the tanky Boss until you've dealt with the massed firepower of its allies. This punishes PCs that ignore the Boss with a bunch of free Damage. It is also one of the few abilities in the game that references Power Ratings directly, as it is the one variable that gives me (and GMs) the most control over how hard PCs get punished for ignoring the Boss. You set the number down and it never changes, no matter what happens in the middle of the Operation.

How effective is it, though? Well, assuming a Squad of 4 PCs of PL5, with two of them being equivalent to a Boss, that leaves a Power Rating of 24 to be distributed around other Grunts, Rivals and Bosses. Does 24 free Damage hurt a PL5 PC? Yes, but it's probably not punishing enough to force all of them to change their strategy, and a single PC with Threshold 7 can facetank it. Should the effect be 2x Power Rating? Power Rating + Tension? Well, either of these risks making the Boss undefeatable unless the PCs focus fire them immediately... But that's kind of the point, isn't it? And yet, arguably the ability is better off being too weak than too strong. See, a version that is too strong would force PCs to play exactly one way to beat the Boss, while the current and weaker version gives them a choice, and helps preserve a sense of agency. It's a complicated issue, basically, so I'm not going to call it a success but I don't think it is a total failure either.

And That's All For Now

And that's it, not just for Bosses but also all of Chapter 1! Woo! I hope that was enlightening. It certainly helped me take notice of a few issues that I hadn't noticed before. They say that you don't really understand something until you can explain it, and that is something I agree with.

I'm going to take a break from the weekly posts for a while. I may do Chapter 2 later, but I want to talk about some other things first. I'll be back with something substantial in the near future, hopefully before the end of the month.

Gimmick Out